John Gerstner and the Renewal of Presbyterian and Reformed Evangelicalism in Modern America

“John Gerstner was a dynamo. His energy was mainly evident to those who heard him speak, but Jeffrey McDonald’s careful biography comes just as close to capturing the vigor that informed the Pittsburgh professor’s voice, heart, and mind. This book is a must read for anyone interested in Calvinistic evangelicalism after World War II.”


—D. G. Hart, Distinguished Associate Professor of History, Hillsdale College, Michigan





“This well-researched book illuminates the career of a scholar, churchman, and memorable teacher who left a major mark on American Christian life.”  


—Mark Noll, Author of America’s God: From Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln





“I commend his work to anyone who seeks a better grasp of orthodox reformed theology in mainline Presbyterian denominations in the twentieth century.”


—Don MacLeod, Research Professor of Church History, Tyndale Theological Seminary, Toronto





“Jeff McDonald demonstrates that his subject, in company with a cohort of fellow United Presbyterians in western Pennsylvania, exercised an influence on American evangelicalism out of all proportion to their numbers.”


— Kenneth J. Stewart, Professor of Theological Studies, Covenant College, Georgia





“A well-researched and engaging biography that portrays the successes, failures, and enduring legacy of this key player in American Reformed evangelicalism.”


—Bradley J. Longfield, Professor of Church History, University of Dubuque Theological Seminary





“This well-researched book illuminates the career of a scholar, churchman, and memorable teacher who left a major mark on American Christian life in the second half of the twentieth century. John Gerstner was sometimes on the losing side of debates among Presbyterians and evangelicals in which he took part, but Jeffrey McDonald explains clearly why those debates deserve careful attention from readers with any interest in the causes that drove Gerstner’s career.”  


—Mark Noll, Author of America’s God: From Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln





“John Gerstner, longtime professor of church history at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary, was a dynamo in the classroom, and as a conference speaker, writer, and church leader. His energy was mainly evident to those who heard him speak and preach, but Jeffrey McDonald’s careful biography of Gerstner comes just as close to capturing the vigor that informed the Pittsburgh professor’s voice, heart, and mind. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in Calvinistic evangelicalism after World War II. Well before the 'young, restless, and Reformed' warmed to Calvinism, John Gerstner made Reformed theology appealing.”


—D. G. Hart, Distinguished Associate Professor of History, Hillsdale College, Michigan





“To date, studies of the post-World War II theological resurgence of American evangelicalism have focused on greater Boston, greater Chicago, and greater Los Angeles. In his John Gerstner, Jeff McDonald demonstrates that his subject, in company with a cohort of fellow United Presbyterians in western Pennsylvania, exercised an influence on American evangelicalism out of all proportion to their numbers.”


— Kenneth J. Stewart, Professor of Theological Studies, Covenant College, Georgia





“John Gerstner was a bellwether figure in confessional American Presbyterian denominational development in the twentieth century. Jeff MacDonald has done us all a great service in researching his hitherto little understood odyssey, which sheds light on how we have arrived where we are today. I commend his work to anyone who seeks a better grasp of orthodox reformed theology in mainline Presbyterian denominations in the twentieth century as well as providing an overview of American Evangelicalism in the same period.”


—Don MacLeod, Research Professor of Church History, Tyndale Theological Seminary, Toronto





“John Gerstner was a major force in twentieth-century Presbyterian and reformed evangelical circles in the United States, but has been largely ignored by historians. Jeffrey McDonald has now remedied that situation and provided a well-researched and engaging biography that portrays the successes, failures, and enduring legacy of this key player in American Reformed evangelicalism.”


—Bradley J. Longfield, Professor of Church History, University of Dubuque Theological Seminary